IVF Patients, Doctors Navigate Fetal Personhood Laws’ Unknowns

IVF Patients, Doctors Navigate Fetal Personhood Laws’ Unknowns

In the summer of 2022, Allison Mertzman and her wife, Leanne, asked their fertility clinic to destroy their embryos.

The married couple were living in California but storing their nine embryos for $3,000 per year at the clinic in Michigan, where Mertzman had resided before. After having two daughters through in vitro fertilization, the couple had decided they wanted more children. But Mertzman was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2021, and the women were waiting for a better time for implantation.

Then, in June 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision overturning the constitutional right to abortion triggered laws in several states establishing “fetal personhood,” or legal rights for embryos beginning at fertilization. The couple wondered: If their frozen embryos were damaged while being moved across states with personhood laws, perhaps because of failed temperature controls, what would the legal ramifications be?

For the then-37-year-old Mertzman and her wife, state abortion and fetal personhood laws had a chilling effect: They chose not to take the risk.

“I was strong-armed into destroying my embryos,” Mertzman said. “I wasn’t ready to implant them for multiple reasons, but overturning Roe v. Wade was the tipping point.”

The laws aren’t just triggering confusion and anguish among IVF patients like Mertzman; they’ve also left clinicians who are tasked with making, storing, testing, and discarding embryos afraid they could face liability.

Fertility doctors worry that the new abortion laws will criminalize standard fertility care and expose them to felony charges or wrongful death lawsuits that are not covered by medical malpractice insurance policies.

Doctors who provide or assist with illegal abortions in states that have bans, such as Texas and Alabama, already face civil penalties of $100,000 or more, revocation of their medical licenses, or prison, including a potential life sentence. Thirteen states have total or near-total abortion bans.

At least 24 states have put some form of fetal personhood language directly into their abortion restrictions or broader civil or criminal statutes. Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Missouri have some of the most sweeping fetal personhood laws related to pregnancy and embryos. In Louisiana, IVF embryos cannot be intentionally destroyed.

Allison Mertzman (left) and her wife, Leanne, wanted more children after having two daughters through in vitro fertilization. But when several states established legal rights for embryos beginning at fertilization, they chose to stop pursuing IVF. (The Mertzman family)

“I think when you have states define personhood at any stage of pregnancy, it opens the door for liability,” said Jessica Waters, a senior scholar in residence at American University. “We’re seeing states try to even criminally charge doctors from other states, so it’s not so far a reach that we will see IVF doctors have liability.”

Waters said standard IVF practices, such as discarding abnormal embryos, or mechanical errors that occur when flash-freezing embryos could also result in lawsuits under wrongful death statutes. These are all “real possibilities,” Waters said.

She said she hopes to see more efforts by states and the federal government to protect IVF doctors from these laws.

“Trump declared himself an IVF president, but under his watch in post-Dobbs, what we’re seeing is a climate where people engaged in reproductive healthcare can’t do their jobs,” Waters said. “I think it really interferes with the good practice of medicine.”

When asked for comment about a lack of prosecutorial safeguards for IVF doctors, White House spokesperson Olivia Wales touted President Donald Trump’s efforts to make IVF more available and less costly. Trump this year proposed a rule that would allow employers to voluntarily expand coverage of fertility benefits, including IVF treatments.

“No president has done more to help Americans struggling to start families than President Trump, whose administration has created a new fertility benefit option and slashed the cost of fertility drugs,” Wales said. “The administration will continue to explore additional policies to build on these historic successes.”

Legal Risks for IVF Doctors

In the meantime, the state laws are prompting doctors to seek more legal consultations, a costly step that can add to their financial pressures.

IVF clinics may also face surging insurance premiums and legal compliance costs in the most restrictive states, said Benjamin McMichael, a professor focused on healthcare law at the University of Alabama.

“We have gone from ‘Embryos are property’ to ‘Embryos are people,’” McMichael said. “And that could change the nature of underlying tort damages, because, certainly, the average person is worth more than property.”

For anti-abortion activists, the difference between an embryo and a person is negligible.

“Personhood laws ensure that there are no arbitrary distinctions about which human lives are acceptable or unacceptable,” said Emma Waters, a senior policy analyst for the Heritage Foundation, which has helped craft fetal personhood laws. “They underscore that the human embryos we create have a right to life.”

Alabama is the only state that gives broad civil and criminal immunity to doctors and allied professionals providing IVF care. Last year, Louisiana enacted legislation protecting clinicians providing IVF care from criminal liability.

That still wasn’t enough to calm Nicole Ulrich’s nerves. Ulrich, director of advocacy at the Fertility Institute of New Orleans, said she avoids even discussing the option of destroying embryos with patients, because Louisiana forbids intentionally destroying embryos left over from IVF treatment.

“My concern is being charged with murder or manslaughter,” Ulrich said. “The new law protects you but is not foolproof or ironclad. It still makes everyone a little nervous.”

She said she explains to patients at the outset that her clinic is not set up for long-term storage. Once embryos are out of state, patients can discuss with their transfer company what to do with embryos.

Some doctors who try to navigate this legal landscape differently fear the consequences. Damla Karsan, founder of Comprehensive Women’s Healthcare in Houston, said performing or aiding an abortion is almost always illegal in Texas. Yet she tries to stay true to the oath she took when she became a physician to help the sick and do no harm.

“I’ve helped multiple patients find care out of state,” Karsan said.

IVF doctors are seeing the changes at their practices. Clinicians say they spend more time counseling patients and answering their questions than before the Dobbs decision took effect.

Patients want to know whether they can limit the number of eggs they make and fertilize during IVF, to limit their liability risk, said Karenne Fru, the founder and medical director at Muna Fertility in Georgia. They want to know whether they are liable if an embryo doesn’t survive the freezing or storage process. They ask what will happen if pre-implantation genetic testing damages their embryos, whether they can transfer multiple embryos all at once, and how to handle miscarriages and ectopic pregnancies.

All the questions are “burdening my staff and myself,” and then some patients decide not to do IVF, Fru said.

But Fru said she makes some adjustments in certain IVF protocols to accommodate patient fears. Sometimes she can stop stimulating a woman’s egg production a day or two earlier than usual, to limit the number of mature eggs they make by 30% — “to optimize outcome but limit risk,” she said.

Patients’ Emotional, Psychological Fallout

When insurance companies and physicians are confused over whether procedures are legal, it can result in delays of necessary or emergency medical treatment and mental anguish for patients. The Heritage Foundation’s Emma Waters said she is “deeply grieved” that women have been made to feel they won’t receive proper medical care because of abortion laws.

Julie Cohen, a senior program manager at the Jewish Fertility Foundation in Birmingham, Alabama, found out eight weeks into her pregnancy in July 2022 that her “baby girl” had lethal anomalies. But at the appointment to sign paperwork for the hospital procedure to deliver her, Cohen said, her insurance company informed her it wouldn’t cover it and she might owe an estimated $20,000. The company thought it wasn’t legal under the state’s abortion ban, despite the state allowing the procedure for lethal fetal anomalies, Cohen said.

The company eventually reversed its denial, but “it was absolute agony to wait,” she said. “I couldn’t imagine what it could be like if someone didn’t have the resources or connections I had.” She was expecting a son by surrogacy this fall.

Lauren Hock had pursued IVF just as Alabama’s abortion and fetal personhood laws unfolded. Her first appointment at the fertility clinic was in June 2022, days after the Dobbs decision. She gave birth to a son in December 2023, two months before Alabama enacted its personhood law.

Lauren Hock had pursued IVF just as Alabama’s abortion and fetal personhood laws unfolded. She gave birth to a son in December 2023, two months before Alabama enacted its “fetal personhood” law. (Dakota Argo)

Then, in August 2025, the 34-year-old accountant was 14 weeks pregnant, again by IVF, when she started to hemorrhage. If the situation became life-threatening, her doctor told her, the state’s abortion ban meant the hospital would have to approve a procedure to end the pregnancy.

Four weeks later, she began hemorrhaging again. This time, the fetus died. So Hock’s doctors no longer needed permission for the procedure.

“People are failing to understand how dire these situations can be and how personal, high-stress, and emotional they could be,” Hock said. “I would have done anything to save my baby at that point, but I also could have lost my life with my baby’s life.”

Hock tried again, because she wanted a larger family. She is expecting her second child by IVF in March.

But the laws are making some women rethink their reproductive choices.

“More and more patients are coming to me scared and need help with decision-making,” said Lauren Berman, a clinical psychologist in Atlanta and a former committee chair with the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. “They wonder if they should move, get pregnant, or even have children after all.”

The new laws have also led many doctors to leave states with the strictest abortion and personhood laws.

According to a study published last year, after the Dobbs decision the number of OB-GYNs in the most restrictive states significantly decreased compared with states with no abortion restrictions.

With the Trump administration attacking nondiscrimination protections for LGBTQ+ people, Mertzman and her wife feared that their parental rights were also at stake. LGBTQ+ parents face significant legal hurdles and varying state laws for establishing parentage through assisted reproduction, said Sonia Suter, the Kahan Family Research professor at the George Washington University Law School.

“In this environment where there’s a lot of antipathy towards nontraditional families, any LGBTQ+ family has legitimate concerns,” Suter said.

Mertzman said she doesn’t regret her decision to have her embryos destroyed.

“I think there were parts I grieved,” she said, “but in the current day and age, I’m confident we made the right choice.”

KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF.
This article first appeared on KFF Health News and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

LĪHUʻE, Hawaiʻi — Dylan Lawton realized something was wrong when he struggled to use his right leg to hit the brakes while driving. Within a matter of hours, scans showed the third-year medical student had a brain tumor. But the island of Kauaʻi, where he was completing his clinical rotation, has no neurosurgeons. So Lawton was medically evacuated on a plane to Straub Benioff Medical Center on O‘ahu, Hawaiʻi’s most populous island. There, the then-27-year-old was diagnosed with a type of lung cancer commonly found in nonsmokers, which was stage 4 and had spread to his brain.
Early in her election-night victory speech, Democrat Keisha Lance Bottoms, Georgia’s next governor, alluded to one of her main campaign promises: granting more low-income adults access to government health insurance. “This win is for the caregiver who can’t afford healthcare and needs Georgia to finally expand Medicaid,” she told a crowd of cheering supporters. The national Democratic landslide that will give the party control of Congress will also sweep Bottoms and other Democratic gubernatorial candidates into office in a handful of states that have for years resisted fully expanding...
The U.S. has officially lost its status as a country where measles is eliminated, a public health triumph secured a quarter century ago. Researchers with direct knowledge of the deliberations on the country’s status told KFF Health News that the Pan American Health Organization reached the conclusion this week: Measles has reestablished regular transmission in the country. PAHO had planned a public announcement on Nov. 17. In public health parlance, measles elimination depends on a country’s sporadic outbreaks ending within a year. That’s no longer happening in the United States.
KFF Health News senior correspondent Julie Appleby joined WBUR’s Here & Now on Nov. 11 to discuss how a fraud crackdown is making Affordable Care Act open enrollment more difficult. Appleby also discussed the expected rise in premiums, deductibles, and copays for Medicare and employer-based healthcare plans on WVXU’s Cincinnati Edition on Nov. 9.
HILLSBORO, N.D. — The Kritzberger family has farmed in the Red River Valley for more than a century. They once had livestock. Now they grow sugar beets, soybeans, and grains. Like many farmers, they labor to balance the books. “We’re in an incredible amount of debt,” Ang Kritzberger said as she walked the farm on a recent fall morning. For the past 10 years, the Kritzbergers have had another worry. Their daughter Nina has Type 1 diabetes. That’s landed the family in a national debate about how to protect patients from high insulin costs. Nina was diagnosed when she was 7. “I slept by her...
CHEROKEE, N.C. — Two months before the deadline to implement new Medicaid work requirements, states had yet to receive detailed guidance from federal health officials on how to exclude Native Americans from those rules, leading to a patchwork of eligibility checks that pose challenges for qualified enrollees trying to keep their health insurance.
The KFF Health News Minute is available every Thursday via direct download or the RSS feed. Nov. 12 Sam Whitehead reads the week’s news: Your phone may know when you’re visiting the doctor, and companies are using that information to sell unproven treatments. Plus, more dads are taking time off to bond with their newborns through state leave programs. Your browser does not support the audio element. Can’t see the audio player? Visit kffhealthnews.org to listen. Nov. 5
KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF. This article first appeared on KFF Health News and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF. This article first appeared on KFF Health News and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
(Maria Fabrizio for WPLN and KFF Health News) Not many 22-year-olds share DJ Mikunda’s enthusiasm for health insurance coverage. “You know what sounds like a good Friday night? It’s looking at health insurance,” he joked. But Mikunda has a reason to be eager. He has gone without coverage since he left home and started working in 2023. He’s now a manager at a gas station in St. Louis. In years past, he has looked at plans on the health insurance marketplace at healthcare.gov — but the options proved overwhelming and a bit too expensive.
If you or someone you know may be experiencing a mental health crisis, contact the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by dialing or texting “988.” He was 72, a retired health administrator who lived alone near Seattle. Laura Prater, a firearms researcher at Ohio State, was interviewing him via Zoom. She’d administered a questionnaire that indicated he had mild cognitive impairment, which is often, but not always, a precursor to dementia. His doctor had also diagnosed him with depression. As part of a study of firearm safety for older adults, Prater asked if he kept a gun in his home. He did....
Eli McCreary of Omaha, Nebraska, said he had recently been diagnosed with kidney cancer when he got a call from a local hospital run by CHI Health. He said he was informed that he wasn’t insured anymore under Medicaid — and that the hospital would cancel his appointments unless he paid out-of-pocket. McCreary, who was 64 at the time, said he phoned a call center for help. He said he was told his benefits under Medicaid, the government health program for people with low incomes or disabilities, now required that he have a job. “You’re required to do work to stay on,” McCreary said a...
KFF Health News chief Washington correspondent Julie Rovner discussed how Congress can combat the rising cost of healthcare on WAMU’s 1A on Nov. 5, healthcare affordability on MS NOW’s Money, Power, Politics With Stephanie Ruhle on Oct. 30, and the politics of healthcare on Slate’s What Next podcast on Oct. 27.
Texas Democrats spent three decades trying to regain control of the governor’s mansion and other top state leadership positions. This Election Day, they pulled off a decisive upset, taking statewide offices and the state House, partly due to voter anger over healthcare costs and the difficulty of getting care. Now the state’s newly elected leaders have two months before the next legislative session to figure out how to deliver on their promises on healthcare affordability and other thorny issues, such as abortion. And they need to do it in the face of bruising political opposition over a...
Healthcare affordability. Abortion access. “Medicare for All.” Healthcare was a major force behind the big wins for Democrats in this week’s midterm elections. But the debate over what the Democratic Party will do next is just getting started. KFF Health News chief Washington correspondent Julie Rovner appeared on WAMU’s Health Hub on Nov. 4 to explore what Democrats might do with their newfound power. However, with President Donald Trump still in office, this blue wave is likely to crash into legislative limits.  Democrats’ Election Rout Is Poised To Dramatically Reorder...
LANSING, Mich. — Fifteen years working as an emergency room nurse has convinced Kim Bogan that the only way to fix the American healthcare system is to tear it down and start over. Her patients arriving for triage are sicker than ever. They can’t afford many of the prescriptions they get in the ER. And sometimes when patients die, she wonders if she could have saved them had she not been caring for five or six other people at once. That’s why she spent the past year shuttling between 12-hour shifts at this city’s Sparrow Hospital and campaigning for Abdul El-Sayed, the Democrat who made “...
Federal leaders overseeing a $50 billion rural health fund missed a critical deadline to announce how much they’ll give states next year, alerting state leaders to the delay with a mass email. A 12-sentence message from Alina Czekai, director of the federal Office of Rural Health Transformation, said officials “discovered an additional administrative process requirement.” The Rural Health Transformation Program, which President Donald Trump touted as an “unprecedented” investment to “revitalize hospitals in our cherished rural communities,” calls for federal regulators to award states shares...
ST. LOUIS — Voters’ sweeping support of Democratic candidates in Tuesday’s midterm election didn’t translate into similarly clear outcomes for ballot initiatives on abortion access and transgender issues. In Missouri, a state that President Donald Trump carried by an 18-point margin in 2024, voters rejected a proposal to ban both abortion and gender-affirming healthcare for transgender minors. Opponents of the measure celebrated the result with a mix of cheers, tears, hugs, and dancing at an election night watch party in St. Louis — as many of the same people had done only two years earlier...
Democrats’ decisive sweep of the U.S. House and Senate in Tuesday’s elections will reshape the direction of federal health policy — setting the stage for oversight investigations, a legislative push to reverse cuts to the Affordable Care Act and Medicaid, and a focus on lowering costs such as insurance premiums and drug prices. The conclusive string of victories sets up Democrats to argue that voters — who said in preelection surveys that healthcare affordability was a top concern — have given them a clear mandate to overturn historic cuts President Donald Trump and Republicans made to public...
In the summer of 2022, Allison Mertzman and her wife, Leanne, asked their fertility clinic to destroy their embryos. The married couple were living in California but storing their nine embryos for $3,000 per year at the clinic in Michigan, where Mertzman had resided before. After having two daughters through in vitro fertilization, the couple had decided they wanted more children. But Mertzman was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2021, and the women were waiting for a better time for implantation.

 

DISCLAIMER: The information found on this Web Site is dynamic and subject to change. Please use the "CONTACT US" section of the Web Site to submit any questions or comments.